|
|
|
|
|
|
HomeShop at BookSurgeSocial ScienceGeneralChildren's Genitals Under the Knife: Social Imperatives, Secrecy, and Shame |
|
|  |
| Customer Reviews: | | Average Customer Review: ( 1 customer reviews )
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
7 of 7 found the following review helpful:
They do what? Jan 23, 2010
By L. Wilson This book has more than you want to know about the bizarre reasons that people mutilate children's genitals. However, we all need to know this information.
Ms. Lightfoot-Klein addresses the horrors of the issue of both male and female circumcision with sympathy for the cultures that practice them. However, she also is clearly opposed. She discusses not only what it means to various cultures, but also how we can begin to work to change the cultures without imposing laws on them or discarding the important parts of the culture (families, languages, arts, etc.). She also makes the point that in most cases, the parents are only trying to do the right thing for their children, but at least a few of the operators have really questionable motives.
Ms.L-K doesn't let the US off the hook, either. Not only is US one of the few countries that medicalized male circumcision, it is the only country that continues to do it even when there is no medical reason. Also, she points out that until a relatively few years ago, baby girls' clitorises were cut off if they were "too long"--Not in Africa, but in the US and until 1977 Blue Cross paid for it. Knowledgeable Africans see this tradition in America and wonder why many Americans are so eager to change the culture of Africa. It sounds a lot like European colonization, except this time it is the culture that is being colonized.
In many areas that practice female genital removal, there is now an attempt to medicalize the procedure. While this will save the lives of some girls, it will continue the practice much longer when local medical authorities are saying that it is a good thing for the girls. Like male circumcision in the US, the claim is made in the face of the facts, which are ignored or distorted.
Not a light read, but a very important one.
|
|  | |
|
|
|
|
|