|  |
| Customer Reviews: | | Average Customer Review: ( 18 customer reviews )
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
15 of 19 found the following review helpful:
 An Insightful Perspective of Surviving Hurricane Katrina Jul 31, 2006
By Deanslist2
Like Robert Smallwood, I, too, am a New Orleans writer who rode out Hurricane Katrina in a French Quarter apartment. I stayed through the storm and for two days afterward until conditions deteriorated so badly that I had to leave, along with the 87 year old woman in my charge. Close to 70% of the people who died during during the storm and as a direct result of it were 65 and over. This woman, strong as she is at her age, probably wouldn't have made it through the conditions we had to endure.
During the storm and for several weeks afterward, including my own evacuation and return to the city a week later, I took notes on a hand-held mini-cassette recorder. Someday I will write my own book on what it was like or I will incorporate my experiences into a broader format. For now I am just trying to survive in a region that was devastated by one of the worst natural and man-made disasters in our nation's history.
For a "reviewer" on solid ground, well above sea level, in West Chester, Pennsylvania to question the credentials of someone who survived this disaster and wrote a book about it, shows incredible ignorance regarding the situation and a lack of basic human sensitivity. Just because the French Quarter didn't flood doesn't mean it got off the hook unscathed. There was a tremendous amount of wind damage done to many of the Quarter's fragile, 200 year-old structures and public places.
The Quarter, along with the rest of the city and most of the region, were without electricity, gas, clean running water and other vital services for an entire month. Police and fire protection and medical services were nonexistent during those chaotic first few days. Law and order completely broke down and tens of thousands of people were left to fend for themselves without essential resources. Let anyone try surviving those kinds of conditions in West Chester, Pennsylvania or anywhere else. Hopefully Dana Y. Boles will never have to experience anything like this, especially during a winter as cold and brutal as the summer of 2005 was hot and steamy here in New Orleans.
Undoubtedly there will be other books written on Katrina from other survivors, some of whom were among those dramatically rescued from rooftops. Those books, and all others written about the disaster -- including Mr. Smallwood's -- are all important contributions to the public record and the world's body of knowlege. These are the time capsules future scholars and others are going to be consulting when they do their research, in much the same way as Samuel Pepys' diaries are used as a reference point on life in London during the restoration of the Stuart monarchy in the 1660s. Especially his account of the Great Fire of London in 1666, an urban catastrophe on a par with that of New Orleans in 2005.
What Mr. Smallwood has done in his book is put a human face on the disaster. It is a slice of life through a window peering into a difficult time, and a testament to how strong, resourceful people survived through it. It may be easy for someone 1,500 miles away to self-righteously pontificate about people looting stores for essentials like food, water and baby supplies, but at that point in time, no one knew the cavalry was on its way with MRE's.
In fact, no one here at Ground Zero knew much of anything. Cell phones were useless, as were most land phone lines. We had no electricity and no TV or computers. The radio stations that managed to stay on the air told us nothing about levee breaks, rescue efforts or anything else that would have helped us better understand our plight. Radio stations here no longer have news crews out reporting on breaking stories. Most of us holed up in the French Quarter didn't know that 80% of the city was underwater or that the water creeping up Canal Street to the edge of the Quarter was coming from a levee breach five miles away. People everywhere else in the country knew more about what was going on than those of us who were here.
Robert Smallwood has given us an excellent accounting of what it was like during a period of anarchy unlike anything anyone in this nation has ever seen within our boundaries. It will stand up to historical scrutiny, and will undoubtedly be consulted as firsthand source material long after all of us are gone. No better praise can be offered than that.
Dean M. Shapiro
7 of 8 found the following review helpful:
 this is the real deal Sep 05, 2006
By Juli Green
"insou2you"
As a resident of the french quarter, and a familiar face in some of the local haunts mentioned in Smallwood's book, I can tell you with certainty that this is a NON FICTION account of hurricane activity in the quarter. I have read negative reviews because Smallwood discusses procuring beer, the "pillhead", et al, but this is how life works in the quarter. We were very blessed to have avoided the flooding that plagued our surrounding areas, and we never forget how lucky we are - but this is not merely an account of hurricane survival in new orleans - it is LIFE in the QUARTER. anyone who knows can tell you that just as New Orleans is a seperate entity from the rest of the country, the Quarter is a locale unto itself. If you want to know how the quarter rats (as we call ourselves) survived Katrina, read this book. Ya heard me, darlin?
8 of 10 found the following review helpful:
Roller Coaster Ride of a Book Jul 18, 2006
By River Dharma
As a New Orleans resident, I read this book with interest. One of the first to come out with a first person account of their experience, Smallwood's book was refreshing. With humor and a writing style that carries you along like you're riding a wave, he recounts his days after Katrina devastated our city. He reveals his sadness as well, and the fear that pervaded the streets. What all of us who were here learned, was that our experience and our perception was uniquely ours, and communication was difficult in any event, so life was very definitely lived in the moment, and in that moment what mattered was survival, both emotional and physical. Smallwood managed to bring his unique experience to these pages with a minimum of over the top angst or political blaming. The book shows us what his "moment" looked and felt like to him. In doing that, he has added to what will inevitably become the "literature of Katrina." He makes no excuses for himself or anyone else, and he shouldn't. Read all the scholarly books on Katrina. Read all the lyrical books about Katrina. They're all worthwhile. But make sure to read Smallwood's book. You'll feel like he's telling you his story over a drink at Molly's.
6 of 8 found the following review helpful:
Another perspective on Katrina's effects. Jul 24, 2006
By C. M. Brooks
When I read a book it is to gain a personal perspective of the lives and events of people different from my own. While Mr. Smallwood's account did not cover the raw grittiness and horrific events that made for so much news in Katrina's aftermath it is an interesting read of another person's experiences. While not downplaying the human tragedy that occurred in New Orleans I enjoyed this other perspective. One thing about New Orleans is it's diversity and Mr. Smallwood's experience, as he relates so well in his book, provides those of us that live on the other side of the continent a different view of New Orleans than the ugly side we saw on the news.
1 of 1 found the following review helpful:
Intriguing Account Feb 20, 2010
By Dawn W
"Dawn Westerberg Consulting"
If you feel you are being challenged by circumstances in your life, a few pages into The Five People You Meet in Hell: Surviving Katrina by Robert Smallwood will provide you with the needed reality check. It did me.
This autobiographical memoir of the days of and following the disastrous hurricane that hit New Orleans in August of 2005 is an eyewitness account of a French Quarter resident.
This book gives a palpable, personal view of the day by day survival of those remaining in the French Quarter. Some rose to heroic heights; some snapped.
The book engaged me - I read it in two sittings unable to put it down. The narrator and his neighbors are memorable.
Personally, I experienced Katrina from the safety of two or three degrees of separation: there was a family from New Orleans who moved into a rental nearby, there was a neighbor with family in New Orleans scrambling to find accommodations for loved ones, there was Sage Business Partner Patricia Welther of Help Solutions in Baton Rouge who set up CRM systems to assist New Orleans businesses - but reading this book gave me a gut-wrenching view that I had not seen before.
I have read the mostly favorable reviews on Amazon. The unfavorable reviews were critical of the personality of the author and/or the specifics of his experience. I find those criticisms to be at best disingenuous and unrealistic. A personal account is just that - personal. There is authenticity (and courage) in sharing the one's own truth. Also, there was criticism that the French Quarter was not hit as hard as other areas, so somehow this account is not the real deal. Again, I was scratching my head as one's experience can only be one's experience.
See all 18 customer reviews on Amazon.com
|
| | |
|
|
